1. strangerfruit
  2. Wilkins, Dear and Darwin on species

Wilkins, Dear and Darwin on species

By jlynch on February 2, 2007.

A short while back I presented a quote by historian Peter Dear regarding Darwin's ideas about species. Of the quote I commented that it was "so wrong it is not even funny". Professor Dear took exception to that comment (especially after John Wilkins waded in with his view) and commented that "[i]f you want to show that I'm wrong about Darwin here,
give me some evidence from Darwin himself, rather than telling us what biologists and philosophers of biology believe nowadays."

Now John has provided the first of a series of posts on the development of Darwin's writings on species. Speaking of the quote by Dear that I originally presented, John notes:

[T]his is egregiously wrong. It is false in almost every important respect. And Dear is not alone in this sort of misunderstanding about Darwin and species. Something like it is stated authoritatively by almost every evolutionary textbook or book on species that appeals to history. It's time to defend Darwin, and look a bit more carefully at what turn out to be rather sophisticated discussions by Darwin for his time.

Tags
History and Philosophy (often of Science)

More like this

Darwin on species, 1
Recently, John Lynch mentioned a short passage in a book by historian Peter Dear, called The intelligibility of nature. Dear wrote this: It is one of the remarkable facts about nineteenth-century natural history that the practices of taxonomists were not thrown into disruption by the eventual…
I'm talking at Berkeley
Those of you who live near San Francisco might be interested in this talk I'm giving at the Pizza Munch gathering at UC Berkeley in November. For November we've made arrangements to meet jointly with the Bay Area Biosystematists in Berkeley on Thursday, November 9. John Wilkins (Queensland) will…
"Pithecophobes of the World, Unite!" (Part I)
Nearly ten years ago I started a book on Creationist misuse of intellectual history. I never finished it, which is probably for the best. The file is unfortunately MIA and all I have remaining was a section that I turned into a talk that I gave at ASU in 1999. Over the next few days, I'll be…
Cordova Steps in it - Again
Ed Brayton, Orac, and the Hoofnagles have already covered this story (click here, here, and here, respectively.) But why should they have all the fun? Over at Uncommon Descent, Salvador Cordova discusses the MacCallum essay, Now, I've seen several of Salvador's public presentations. So I am…