Neuroethics with a Dose of Realism, from Neuroscience 2007

Today's festivities featured a great talk on neuroethics. Actually, it was one of the first truly good talks I've heard about neuroethics. The speaker was Martha Farah, director of the University of Pennsylvania's Center for Cognitive Neuroscience. She skipped the dreadful sci-fi speculation that peppers so many talks on neuroethics and stuck to the facts, providing a broad but compelling overview of the current practice of neuro-enhancement. And rather than waffling about over the ethics, she concluded with strong recommendations—specifically, she recommended that there be more public funding for neuro-enhancement and neurotechnologies. If we keep the balance of power in the private sector, she said, the development of ethically questionable neurotechnologies and drugs may never be transparent. The relevant risks may never be disclosed, and we may not have the public debate we need before new products come to market.

It was a thought-provoking, somewhat counter-intuitive argument, but (I thought) a convincing one. Also, she won major points for her explanation of why she'd decided not to try to condense the entire history of neuroscience onto one slide: "This is something that even Michael Mukasey would regard as a form of torture." Bravo, Dr. Farah, bravo.

Tags

More like this

When last we heard from Christopher Monckton he was too gravely ill to answers questions about how someone claiming to be him and using his ISP had altered his own wikipedia entry and added on obvious fabrication, to wit, The Guardian "is reported to have paid Monckton £50,000 in damages.".…
This time had to come: A group that includes some serious neuro-heavyweights, such as neuroscientists Michael Gazzaniga and Ronald Kessler and the highly prominent and influential neuroethicists Hank Greely and Martha Farah, has published in Nature an essay "Towards responsible use of cognitive-…
Anthony Dunne's call for mass speculation (in political science, genetics, ethics, economics, pretty much every discipline) is founded on a refreshing optimism. Dunne: "Today we don't just need solutions, we also need dreams." He is right—designers that are too polite to take chances and postulate…
An FT article: Poverty in early childhood poisons the brain, the American Association for the Advancement of Science meeting in Boston yesterday heard. Neuroscientists said many children growing up in very poor families with low social status experience unhealthy levels of stress hormones, which…