Mutagen X (Yeah, I picked it just for the name)

I hadn't heard of this one before today: Mutagen X.

i-928b8984deaa8e173f7f44d086ef767b-mutagen-x.png

Mutagen X is apparently a byproduct of water chlorination, which isn't so surprising - chloroform (CHCl3) can occur in chlorinated water. This MX stuff is much worse, apparently. Anyone know the immediate source of the carbon?

More like this

Here is another molecule that's gone out of favor in recent decades: carbon tetrachloride: Chlorinated solvents are great solvents. Something about the polarizability, medium polarity, (relative) lack of reactivity, just makes them the only thing that will work in a lot of applications. The three…
The urea entry ended up with a discussion in the comments I encourage you to read about early organic chemists, one of whom was Kolbe, who first prepared acetic acid (an indisputably organic and biologically relevant molecule) from inorganic compounds. He worked with Wohler (mentioned in the urea…
There's a lot to know about influenza that we don't know. Unfortunately a lot of is things you thought we knew but don't. Like whether there is a risk from influenza virus in drinking water. Admittedly this hasn't been at the top of the list for seasonal flu, since the main reservoir for this virus…
Chlorinated solvents are great solvents. The polarizability of chlorine, moderate electronegativity, moderate volatility, lack of acidic protons or reactivity - it all adds up to a great reaction medium. However, they usually are toxic. Carbon tetrachloride, CCl4, used to find a lot of use, even in…

As with chloroform, the carbon source is usually humic acids.

I'm a water engineer (BS in Chem Eng, MS in Environmental Eng). I'm not sure, but I would guess that the carbon comes from humic or fulvic acids, i.e. NOM (natural organic matter) that is naturally present in surface water, and occasionally groundwater. It's not a single simple molecule, it's a whole family of complex organic soup. I personally haven't heard of Mutagen X, though there are all kinds of disinfection byproducts (DBPs) out there. Chloroform is the most common. THMs (trihalomethanes, of which chloroform is obviously one) and HAAs (haloacetic acids) are the ones that are regulated by the SDWA (safe drinking water act). Is that enough TLAs for you? (three letter acronyms)

Yeah, I've read the "humic acid" explanation, and maybe I'm showing my ignorance, but can't we do a little better? Five-membered lactenones always remind me of ascorbate. Anyone have any idea what the real precursor is? It can't be that diverse a range of substrates for transformation by what amounts to chlorine radical.

Looks like the carbon could have come from an isoprene, but those can come from practically anywhere.

By Cranberry (not verified) on 12 Nov 2007 #permalink

I remember the story in Peru where they were worried about trihalomethanes causing cancer in drinking water. So they stopped chlorinating the water for a while, and many died from water-borne bacterial diseases. I'd rather drink THM's than, say, cryptosporidium, etc.