Noah Feldman on the contradictions of a religious community facing modernity in NY Times. If you read an essay on the contradictions of orthodoxy by anyone at any time in history, you will find the same themes discussed. Ignorance empowered by authority will always be at odds with Science, regardless of how well they've learnt to split hair and write finer points on the margins of oversized books.
Couldn't the contradictory world from which we sprang be just as rich and productive as the contradictory life we actually live? Would it really, truly, have made all that much difference? Isn't everyone's life a mass of contradictions?
asks Feldman. Is it? Or is it that the ones whose life is a mass of contradictions are the ones who need religion to justify their existence?
- Log in to post comments
More like this
Karen Armstrong has once again published a pile of meaningless twaddle in defense of religion. In this mess, she takes a series of statements about god that she says need rethinking…but as always, her "rethinking" is merely a reworking of apologetics for maintaining the status quo. It's almost as…
Noted sockpuppet and sniveler Lee Siegel warns us that the new militant atheists may be closing the book on imagination. And for some reason the LA Times saw fit to publish this tripe.
In the last few years, so many books have rolled off the presses challenging God, belief and religion itself (…
Life is about choices made in the context of scarcity and constraint. In an ideal world (OK, my ideal world) I would be dictator, and all would do my bidding and satisify most proximate desires. Alas, it doesn't work that way. We all have to jump through hoops to get where we want. Whatever…
It's mildly ironic that the recent Dawkins discussion has centered around whether he does or does not do an adequate job of addressing the logical arguments for the existence of God, because that's one of the few areas where I probably agree with him. I don't find any of those arguments…
Interview with Feldman about breaking Orthodoxy.
http://www.jewcy.com/daily_shvitz/questions_for_the_author_of_orthodox_…
Thanks for the link. A thoughtful interview.
"a skewed and distasteful takedown that encourages non-Jews to gawk at the internal problems of a modern Orthodox Jewish community. Or maybe its a poignant and brave discussion of the challenges of bringing a traditional faith into modern life", thus starts the Q&A. What shouldn't non-jews 'gawk'? It's a pleasure and I don't want anyone deny me that. As for the challenges of bringing traditional faith into modern life, there's nothing new in it. Everyone who hasn't embraced rationality thoroughly is doing it in one way or other, and invariably failing in the endeavor.