From Russell Roberts at Cafe Hayek:
There are two ways to reduce the connection between politicians and money. One is to reduce the role of money. The other is to reduce the role of politicians. I choose the latter. I contend that reducing the role of money of politics in order to make politics more honest is like trying to make airplanes safer by reducing the role of gravity. Let's get money out of politics by making politicians less powerful.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
Many people have been discussing the structural impediments to passing legislation, or what is often called legislative gridlock. As Matthew Yglesias put it:
The smarter elements in Washington DC are starting to pick up on the fact that it's not tactical errors on the part of the president that…
Part 1 | 2 | 3 | 4
- - -
Part 4 with Jody Roberts and Michelle Murphy--discussing her book Sick Building Syndrome and the Problem of Uncertainty--follows below. All entries in the author-meets-blogger series can be found here.
- - -
WF: The book is titled "Sick Building Syndrome and the…
Astrology has never so far as I know proposed a scientific mechanism by which the planets should affect the lives of us mortals. I suppose this is fair enough, you wouldn't expect magic to work by normal laws. If the position of Jupiter says you should spend the rest of the week face down in the…
Inevitably, with the announcement of The March for Science on Earth Day, April 22nd of this year, come the inevitable naysayers decrying the politicization of science. Astroturf groups such as ACSH (diversity excludes white dudes and scientists from industry!), have of course decried the effort as…
There is just one problem: the connection of politicians and money isn't the real issue any more than you can claim that the connection of gas and and cars causes accidents.
In a relatively free capitalist society, as opposed to a pure dictatorship where you can get it all done by issuing an order, you have to pay for work to get done. Even the necessary work that a government does, or at least should do. Money is just the fuel that is used to get things done.
As with the car, where it isn't the gas causing the problems, it isn't the money causing the problems with politicians. In both cases it is a matter of control.
The car goes off the road or runs into other cars because it isn't under control. A politician runs into problems because he/she isn't under control.
The problem is that politicians too often are not under the detailed control and observation of the citizenry. This is a result of insider and backroom deals and the ability of politicians to either prevent the information from getting out to distort the message if it does. In both case it often has to do with a press corp that has become a lap dog. The average citizen has neither the time nor the inclination to maintain the necessary level of surveillance over their elected officials and the politicians. They have work and sleep and raising a family to fill their day. Also, politicians, knowing they benefit from dark corners and inside deals, don't make it any easier.
What is needed is a pool of dedicated investigators who specialize in following the issues, trends, activities and sins of just one or two politicians and follow and report on their every move 24/7/365.
The press has been co-opted, bought off and tamed. That is the problem.
Power exists, in the necessity for people to make decisions in their lives and the effect of others on those decisions. If politicians have less power, that power will be excercised without accountability. Your 'philosopher' sounds like a stalking horse for fascism.
What we need is more accountability: Corporations by the people, for the people.