Back when I first mentioned the idea, people were kind of down on the idea of SciRate.com, Dave Bacon's project to make a collaborative filter for the arxiv.org prerprint server. Not one to be easily discouraged, Dave has continued to work on it, and it now features papers from all the different arxiv categories, instead of just quant-ph.
If you've been sitting around thinking "Gee, I wish there were a Digg for hep-th, well, today's you're lucky day. If you haven't, well, umm... Look over there! Shiny thing!
- Log in to post comments
More like this
Sorry for the ridiculously slow pace around here lately; I've been
ridiculously busy. I'm changing projects at work; it's the end of the school
year for my kids; and I'm getting close to the end-game for my book. Between
all of those, I just haven't had much time for blogging lately.
Anyway... I…
Well today is my thesis defense day. For those who are unfamiliar with the process, this is how it works at least at my university.
When you start out in a lab you do the experiments your boss tells you to do, with the goal of picking up a project. This usually involves taking up where another…
One thing that continually amazes me is the amount of email I get from
readers of this blog asking for career advice. I usually try to just politely
decline; I don't think I'm particularly qualified to give personal
advice to people that I don't know personally.
But one thing that I have done…
You'll hear a lot today about Martin Luther King and race. But what you won't hear nearly as much about, particularly from conservatives, is his views on economic justice. I think that his views on race were inseparable from his economic views which were based on a universal call for justice and…
Shame if it leads to people overlooking less fashionable papers because they don't get rated highly by enough people.
I also think it would be a shame if less fashionable papers are overlooked because of something like this. However my experience so far has been exactly the opposite in that paper that I normally wouldn't have read, I've ended up reading because people I respect voted or them.
I'm also a bit curious about how often "real" results get overlooked. Maybe I'm just naive because I've got blinders on in a particularly narrow field, but my impression is rarely that this happens. And I do read voraciously. I wonder how you would test this :)
There are lots of questions I'd have about the preprints and how they are read (or not), that would be interesting to research on. Basically, I guess, what are the common internal sorting algorithms that people run, when looking at the preprints list, how they filter what to read based on title, author, hearing from other people plus, of course, seeing what papers cite your own and scanning them, that sort of stuff.
Not to mention other essential components such as:
if (author == Werner)
{
int days = 3;
backside.sit(officeChair);
eyes.read(days, hands.fetchMathBooks("all"));
selfEsteem--;
}