Simmer on low heat, stir occasionally

That's my recipe for dealing with crackpots; feel free to use it, it's easy.

You all may remember Vincent Fleury, the French fellow who ascribes developmental processes to swirls of cellular movement in development, who wrote a peculiar paper in a European journal of applied physics (which I mocked mercilessly), and who then went crying to fringe journalist Suzan Mazur, and then demanded withdrawal of my review and an apology. He's done it again. I just received a copy of a letter from France, which was also sent to the vice chancellor of academic affairs of my university, demanding that I be gently chastised. He claims he is the "victim of a fierce attack". If you really must know all the details, here are some scans of the letter.

i-db23e56d35ffc3b7c4efcc4e21715545-fleury1-thumb-200x283-22039.jpeg i-67eacecda0e3810c147edb37e5a668d6-fleury2-thumb-200x283-22042.jpeg

Just a gentle hint for future complaints: the vice chancellor's name is Cheryl Contant, not "Content", and she should be addressed as Dr Contant, not Mrs Content. You're welcome.

Otherwise, there's nothing in his letters that I think needs to be answered.

Tags

More like this

There are science crackpots, and then there are journalist crackpots. Suzan Mazur is a strange writer who runs about trying to convince the world that there is going to be a revolution in evolutionary biology…but her sources tend to be fringe figures like Stuart Pivar, or she relies on mangling…
I was recently sent a strange article for comment…well, not that recently. It's 51 pages long, so I've kind of dragged my heels over it all. I have finally finished it, though, and it is weird. There is a significant tradition in developmental biology that is currently a bit out of fashion: some…
Spare me the obsessed. Vincent Fleury is still haranguing me over my review of his bad paper. He argues for a simplistic mechanical view of development, saying "Tetrapods are formed by a flow of cells which has a hyperbolic (saddle) point around the navel. it is not tautological. They form from the…
Clarifying tetrapod embryogenesis, accurately By OldCola [Note from pzm: The text of this one is a little rougher than I like, but the content is interesting and addresses the claims of a character who has been lurking about here for a while, and whose work I've criticized before. If nothing else…