Happy Morning After Cephalopodmas, everyone!

Are you all as exhausted from the festivities as I am? I partook a little too heavily of the traditional Driving-Long-Distances-In-The-Snow-To-Pick-Up-Returning-Progeny-Whose-Bus-Was-Over-An-Hour-Late part of the celebration, which means my brain is turning over a little slowly this morning. I'm going to sit and sip coffee for a while, and read some Science…expect something on the phosphatized embryos later!

Tags

More like this

I'm back after the traditional family holiday and a less traditional trip to Charleston, SC for the Renaissance Weekend meeting. Which means things will start to return to what passes for normal around here, and that means it's time to get caught up on photo-a-day pictures... What with one thing…
Another in my marathon posts, but! To a new city, Rotterdam. Which is indeed a fairly new city, having been bombed to buggery (by us, mostly, I presume [update: no, I'm wrong, it was the Krauts]) during WW II. Anyway, TL:DR: 3:55:53. Which is one second slower than Amsterdam 2012. Here's my list,…
This is my least favorite time of the year in Minnesota. I hate early spring. Everything is melting during the day: there's a constant drip-drip-drip, puddles everywhere, the snow is shrinking away from all those untrammeled areas surrounding us, and during the day, the walkways are all like…
This will be a quiet week - I've got my Dad making his annual visit, a talk, a short trip, and then a slew of guests arriving for the weekend for Simon's 9th birthday party and Simon's first Torah reading (he's too young to read in the main synagogue, but he'll be the youngest kid ever to chant…

Nice example of the "no true Scotsman" fallacy by the Right Rev. Bishop Dunn, too.

By Jeff Chamberlain (not verified) on 23 Dec 2006 #permalink

What is that fallacy?

By David Marjanović (not verified) on 23 Dec 2006 #permalink

The "No True Scotsman" fallacy goes something like this:

Andy says: All Scotsmen eat porridge in the morning.
Ben says: My uncle is a Scotsman, and he doesn't eat porridge.
Andy replies: Then he isn't a true Scotsman.

It is frequently used by the religious to disassociate themselves from someone who would seem to disprove an assertation they would like to make, such as "No Christian would ever swear." When you point out that your mother, who is a Christian, swears, they might respond with "No true Christian would swear." or "Then she isn't really a Christian." or something similar.

What is that fallacy?

By David Marjanović (not verified) on 23 Dec 2006 #permalink