1. mixingmemory
  2. The Underread

The Underread

By mixingmemory on June 28, 2006.

Jonah, over at Frontal Cortex, has a post titled "Neglected Psychologists," in which he asks:

What other great scientists of mind are modern neuroscientists neglecting?

The same could be asked of all cognitive scientists. Jonah gives two names: William James and John Dewey. If you've been reading this blog for long, you know that I'm a huge James fan, and Dewey is an excellent choice as well. In coments, I added Frederic Bartlett, whose book Remembering should be read by anyone interested in cognitive or social psychology, and Kurt Lewin, who has already been profoundly influential, but who definitely deserves a wider audience among psychologists. Lewin's Dynamic Theory of Personality is a truly amazing work. I should probably have added Maurice Merleau-Ponty (Clark probably saw that coming), whose The Structure of Behavior alone should serve as a guide for how and how not to approach the mind scientifically. It also contains a wonderful critique of behaviorism, especially in the first couple chapters, and we all know that cognitive scientists love to read a good critique of behaviorism. In this case, however, cognitive scientists today constantly risk committing the same errors that M-P saw in behaviorism. All the more reason to read it. It probably wouldn't be so bad if cognitive scientists also read Bergon's Matter and Memory, and for a completely different perspective, Norman Malcolm's Memory and Mind, or just "Memory and Representation."

So, who would you add to the list?

Tags
History of Psychology

More like this

In Defense of Freud
A couple Science Bloggers have been giving Freud a hard time lately. In a post on Malcolm Gladwell's Blink, Jonah Lehrer of The Frontal Cortex wrote: So why was Blink less than satisfying for me? Becase Gladwell ended up lumping together all sorts of research, from Damasio's Iowa Gambling Task to…
Neglected Psychologists
Mixing Memory's post on the undeserved obscurity of Franz Brentano got me thinking. What other great scientists of mind are modern neuroscientists neglecting? My own vote goes to William James. While his Principles of Psychology are often mandatory reading in Intro to Psych courses - not bad for a…
The Neglected
So we now have a short list of some great but forgotten psychologists: Karen Horney: "Neurosis and Human Growth" Frederic Bartlett: "Remembering" Kurt Lewin William James: "Pragmatism" Alfred Adler Edward Tolman John Dewey George Mead Keep the suggestions coming!
Freud as Literature; Freud as Science
In a response to my defense of Freud, Jonah Lehrer states that, with Harold Bloom (ewww!), he sees Freud as "one of the great artists of the 20th century." In my view, how we read Freud today -- as literature, philosophy, or science -- is largely a matter of choice, as is the case for most early…