Resistant Bacteria Stick Around for a Long Time

Well, it's a better title than "Duration of Stool Colonization in Patients Infected with Extended-Spectrum Beta-Lactamase-Producing Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae." What the authors were looking at is how long E. coli and K pneumoniae (another opportunistic commensal that is found in people at low densities) that carry resistance genes that encode enzymes known as ESBLs (extended-spectrum beta-lactamases).

ESBLs confer resistance to many of the antibiotics that start with "cef-" (or "ceph-") or that end in "-cillin" making these drugs ineffective at treating these infections.

On average, a patient who had been in the hospital for a week or longer would shed (i.e., poop) ESBL-producing bacteria for 98 days. If patient were given antibiotics to take home, they would shed ESBL-producing bacteria for 154 days (the median for those not given antibiotics was 56 days).

The good news is that this rate of strain turnover (the length of time that a bacterial strain resides in a person) isn't longer than what we usually observe for most E. coli in healthy people (a few weeks to several months). The bad news is that this isn't shorter than what we see in healthy people either. That means the survival of these resistant strains might be largely dependent on features of their ecology other than antibiotic resistance. Once these E. coli leave the hospital, they might be as fit as any other E. coli, which means that responsible use of antibiotics, while absolutely necessarily, doesn't act very quickly.

Cited article: Apisarnthanarak A., T.C. Bailey, and V.J. Fraser. 2008. Duration of Stool Colonization in Patients Infected with Extended-Spectrum Beta-Lactamase-Producing Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae. Clinical Infectious Diseases 46:1322-1323.

More like this

I've written before about CTX-M-15 beta-lactamases which make bacteria resistant to most cephalosporin antibiotics--those antibiotics that begin with cef- (or ceph-) or end with -cillin. I've also discussed the role of clonal spread in the rise of antibiotic resistance: most (but obviously not…
I'm conflicted about Nicholas Kristof's recent op-ed about antibiotic resistant organisms. On the one hand, Kristof is one of the only national columnists to raise this issue at all. On the other hand, I found his most recent column somewhat confusing--and I'm an expert in this area (I also think…
Since I haven't discussed antibiotic resistance for a while, I want to put that health problem in context. The CDC estimates that every year, over 60,000 U.S. residents die from a hospital-acquired bacterial infection that is resistant to one or more commonly used antibiotics. Roughly 25,000 per…
I've posted before about the possible approval of cefquinome in agriculture, and why this is a stupid thing to even consider. So some colleagues and I got cranky and wrote a letter to the FDA. Here's the letter: Andrew C. von Eschenbach, M.D. Acting Commissioner U.S. Food and Drug Administration…