Heather Mac Donald, 2 years ago on God

I just found this article by Heather Mac Donald in Slate, Send a Message to God: He has gone too far this time. She published it two years ago, and somehow I missed it!

Tags

More like this

She has so much of it to spread around, too. Sarah Palin's memoir reveals her unsurprising opinion about evolution. Elsewhere in this volume, she talks about creationism, saying she "didn't believe in the theory that human beings — thinking, loving beings — originated from fish that sprouted legs…
Josh has a good overview of the wending through the legislature of a Creationist bill in Louisiana. The governor of Louisiana, Bobby Jindal, who just turned 37, has made Creationist noises before. This is interesting because Jindal is a Roman Catholic, so he has no necessary religious rationale…
Sarah Palin's new book does not contain an index. So Christopher Beam, writing at Slate made one for her! Not that you were planning to read the book anyway, but this will save you the trouble. If for some reason you want to know more about the book, have a look at the review in The New York…
I’ve been debating whether to write about this for a while now, given that the first article that I noticed about it was first published a week and a half ago. Part of the reason for my reluctance is that it would be too easy for politics to be dragged into this more than I generally like. Of…

Love that! I never understood how believers can be so blind. Every good thing is a miracle. 2 people die, 2 survive. Its a miracle the 2 survived. Well if its a miracle the 2 survived, did god kill the other 2? weird!

Seems similar to the theology of Julian the Apostate and Fight Club. "You've won, Galilean!" combined with "You have to consider the possibility that God does not like you."

Dear Heather,

I have given the managers, the coaches, and the players the freedom to make their individual tactical decisions. I made strategic decisions that would seem incomprehensible to you, even if I tried to explain. I umpire, you play, have as much fun as you can. Your alloted innings will end soon enough.

-God

As a non-predeterminism Christian, my question to you is why is God supposed to make the world a perfect and perfectly safe place? Maybe we should be smart enough not to build under teh eaves of a snow covered mountain and therefore avoid teh issue of avalanche completely, or perhaps the earth is simply an uncontrollable whimsical thing which occasionally has tsunamis. There is never a guarantee in the Bible that he'll make baby-proof the world for us and keep us from natural harm. It even states clearly that we will suffer at the hands of other humans.

Non-believers love to say if He exists, why do bad things happen, and that solves the problem for them. For a believer who wasn't raised in any kind of religious environment and came to it later in life, my question to you is why do you think he would prevent the natural world from being exactly what it is (dangerous at times without malice) or mankind from causing suffering to itself?

Love that! I never understood how believers can be so blind. Every good thing is a miracle. 2 people die, 2 survive. Its a miracle the 2 survived. Well if its a miracle the 2 survived, did god kill the other 2? weird!

Expand your horizons, not all believers will say that anything is a miracle, much less that everything is a miracle. However, if it makes our life better to be thankful that the 2 survived, don't try to make me feel bad about it. Miracle or not that it happened, relief and happiness that someone survived is a much better reaction in my opinion than the view that there is no meaning to life or the specifics of what happens.

If God is what Christians say he is, showing up in church or not showing up would make no difference. Christianity at its core is not a democracy with opinion polls and changeagble policies. Misused, misdirected, and misunderstood? Yes, that is all possible, but it is just as possible that those words describe the agnostics and athiest as well.