Doubts About Nuclear Energy as a "Middle Way" in the Global Warming Debate

i-10029a9b8a70d43d65f9816b30b2ac8f-mapofplants.gif

As I've noted, in places like Canada and Europe, nuclear energy has been successfully reframed as an important "middle way" compromise solution in the debate over what to do about global warming. Now a report out today from the Oxford Research Group casts doubt on the potential of nuclear. From Reuters:

The surge in political popularity of nuclear power as a quick-fix, zero-carbon solution to global warming is misguided and potentially highly dangerous, a group of academics and scientists said on Monday. In its report "Secure energy, civil nuclear power, security and global warming", the Oxford Research Group said there was not enough uranium available and nuclear nations would therefore tend to opt for reprocessing spent fuel to obtain plutonium. "A multiplication of reprocessing and the resulting international trade in weapons-useable materials would create more opportunities for states, criminal organisations or terrorists to acquire weapons-useable materials," it said.

More like this

In a column last year, I detailed the historical trajectory in the U.S. of frames on nuclear energy, with images moving from very positive interpretations centered on social progress and economic development during the 1950s and 1960s to a very negative focus on public accountability and a Pandora'…
Iran claims Bushehr nuclear power station is "logistically complete" That means it is ready to be loaded with fuel and ought to be just a turn-key from being operational. Russia is reportedly holding back fuel for 2 months, pending UN process. Iran claims it has paid Russia in full and wants the…
...the USA has not gotten all of its highly-enriched uranium back.  As reported in a special report in the Chicago Tribune, the USA had a program in the '50's and 60's called "Atoms for Peace."  Initially, we supplied low-grade uranium fuel to countries that pledged to not develop nuclear weapons…
Sipping from the internet firehose... This weekly posting is brought to you courtesy of H.E.Taylor. Happy reading, I hope you enjoy this week's Global Warming news roundup (skip to bottom) Top Stories:Meetings - UNFCCC, G8 & OECD, Nargis, US Climate Bill, IEA Report, Late Comments Food…

Matthew -

I'm curious about your attitude toward the usefulness/effectiveness of "reports" like this by advocacy bodies. As is common, this report restates information, ideas and arguments that are not new. From the advocates' perspective, is the idea here that the packaging and issuance of a "report" creates news media attention? What other role or roles do they play in the public discourse?

If big-government, nanny-state market interference had a poster child, the cooling towers of a nuclear plant would be it.