Balko on Hotel Porn Ban

A coalition of conservative groups took out full page ads around the country urging the justice department to ban porn movies in hotel rooms. Radley Balko has the perfect response:

Here's an idea, fundies: Don't order the boobies. If you don't order them, they won't show up in your room.

Although, ironically, there was a report from a hotel manager a few years back whose hotel hosted a big religious right conference. He said that the hotel actually set a record for most money made on hotel room porn that weekend. I'm sure it was just for research purposes.

More like this

I'm up way too early with jet lag, looking over Twitter, and ran into Nick Falkner's report on the TED panel I moderated at Worldcon, which reminded me that I never did write anything about the con. Late is probably still better than never, so here are some quick long-after-the-fact comments about…
I have written and deleted this post. Twice. But damn it, it needs to be said. I'm here in charming Montreal for the North American Congress of Epidemiology. It's a good-sized meeting, as far as epi meetings go. The site notes that it's a joint effort between four major Epi organizations: The…
One of the top players in college basketball this year was Texas freshman Kevin Durant, whose team lost over the weekend. Durant is 6'10", and averaged something like 30 points a game from January on, so the automatic assumption is that he's going to enter the NBA draft, where he would be one of…
“All sins have their origin in a sense of inferiority otherwise called ambition.” -Cesare Pavese We're halfway through the year at Starts With A Bang, but it feels like the greatest things are just getting started! For one, enjoy our newest podcast: on Interstellar Travel, highlighted by an…

Ed, you're staying in the wrong hotels. In the better places, they show up without your having to order them.

:-)

Although, ironically, there was a report from a hotel manager a few years back whose hotel hosted a big religious right conference. He said that the hotel actually set a record for most money made on hotel room porn that weekend. I'm sure it was just for research purposes.

Report from where?

By Anonymous (not verified) on 23 Aug 2006 #permalink

Gee, and I was going to start a boycott of these same hotels because they only have straight porn. I strongly believe the world needs more porn and less dogma. What ever happened to the less government idea? Wasn't that a Republican plank?

I guess Anonymous is looking for someone to do a little hard-core research for them?

Damn religious nuts can't do anything for themselves... EEWWW! I guess they can...

If memory serves, the hotel was in Charlotte, North Carolina. But I'm afraid I'm working from memory here and I may be mistaken. It's been several years since I saw the report.

Although, ironically, there was a report from a hotel manager a few years back whose hotel hosted a big religious right conference. He said that the hotel actually set a record for most money made on hotel room porn that weekend.

Doesn't irony normally involve confounding expectations?

By Ginger Yellow (not verified) on 23 Aug 2006 #permalink

He said that the hotel actually set a record for most money made on hotel room porn that weekend.

That's entirely unsurprising. A person with very conservative religious faith is most likely to be susceptible to temptation, and hence most likely to believe that everyone else is also and therefore we should all be removed from it.

One wonders if the christianet survey was "freeped." Heck, if I'd known about it, I would have signed in to skew the data.

WRT the hotel porn record, I have a friend whose family owns a tourist trap mall in a Large Bible Belt Tourist Destination, who tells me that when the fundie youth orgaizations come to town on field trips, shoplifting skyrockets. They haven't done an actual survey, but I'd be willing to bet that the pilfered products are things the kids are ashamed to take to the register, and wouldn't buy in their home towns where "word might get around."

Ed's right. For support of his contention, see John Dicker's article in 5280, cited by this piece by the EA (scroll down to about midway):

In conservative Cincinnati, for example, one cable operator will only carry Pleasure, TEN's single X channel. However, as Boenish [Oh, grow up.] notes, market research consistently shows that the more conservative a community is, the more adult entertainment is purchased - often on the order of a usage rate that's up to 100% higher than in other markets.
"The Bible Belt is awesome for us," Boenish says with barely restrained glee.

I find this hilarious, since the guy leading the charge in the MSNBC article, Phil Burress, is from Cincinatti!

A large SAS Radisson Hotel in Oslo, Norway talked about stopping porno on their pay per view.

The problem was that the maids were getting sick of walking in on businessmen with their pride out. Apparently some of the men also thought that the action from the screen would be reenacted with the naughty maid.

I don't know if this is a general problem in hotels, or just the Norwegian way of trying to remove the dangerous porn?

By Soren Kongstad (not verified) on 23 Aug 2006 #permalink

I went to a private Christian college in Tennessee, studying for the ministry. Having grown up secular, I had pretty simple entertainments (mostly caving and cliffing), but who do you think we had to help up the stairs, clean up, and put to bed? Right. The ministers' kids. Having grown up with every choice made for them they just fell apart at the smallest bit of freedom. All of the discipline they ever had was externally applied so they never developed any of their own. It was as if their parents had done all their homework for them K-12.

Of course the religious wackies want porn out of hotels. Do have any idea how hard it is for them to abuse women or molest childern when they can hear you in the next room wacking-off?

The problem was that the maids were getting sick of walking in on businessmen with their pride out. Apparently some of the men also thought that the action from the screen would be reenacted with the naughty maid.

If the businessmen have trouble distinguishing between porn and reality, I don't think the hotels can really be blamed for it. Perhaps those men should seek professional help.

I guess Anonymous is looking for someone to do a little hard-core research for them? Damn religious nuts can't do anything for themselves... EEWWW! I guess they can...

J-Dog, don't assume. All I did was ask Ed for a reference.

The link you gave quotes the results of an online poll, so it is potentially very inaccurate - plus, I wouldn't put it past the "analysts" at ChristaiNet to make their problem sound worse than it is.

Still, I wouldn't be surprised...

By Anonymous (not verified) on 23 Aug 2006 #permalink

A large SAS Radisson Hotel in Oslo, Norway talked about stopping porno on their pay per view.

The problem was that the maids were getting sick of walking in on businessmen with their pride out...

Sounds to me like the problem is that Oslo hotels don't have locks. Or the businessmen aren't using them...

Although, ironically, there was a report from a hotel manager a few years back whose hotel hosted a big religious right conference. He said that the hotel actually set a record for most money made on hotel room porn that weekend. I'm sure it was just for research purposes.

I thought they didn't show up on the bill? Uh-oh ...

Funny how certain groups can't take responsibility for their own decisions and need big brother to do it for them.

By freelunch (not verified) on 23 Aug 2006 #permalink

My cousin works as a night auditor at a large chain hotel in the Bible Belt of Virginia, so he sees exactly what charges each room accrues. He claims that when the hotel hosts Southern Baptist functions, which it often does, the spank-o-vision orders pour in at unaparalleled rates.

"Indeed, three years ago, when a local video retailer in Utah was prosecuted for peddling hard-core pornography, he successfully argued that his products were consistent with what his neighbors were watching on pay-per-view:"

http://www.thenewatlantis.com/archive/6/jrosen.htm

I remember the case, I think. As I recall it, the cable records he used in his defense included the pay-per-view records of the hotels. Hotels, which, ironically, the people seeking prosecution had financial interests in.

By Dale Austin (not verified) on 24 Aug 2006 #permalink