Won't the Real Dave Fafarman Please Stand Up?

This is interesting. Yesterday, someone claiming to be Larry Fafarman's brother, Dave, left a comment here. Larry is claiming that it's not really his brother. But then another Dave Fafarman shows up and says he's the real one and demanding the removal of the first one. Now, as you might imagine, I find this whole thing quite amusing.

However, at least one thing that the first brother said has been confirmed: he is indeed a member of the NCSE. That's not the sort of thing that would be public knowledge about Larry's brother, so that would seem to lend credibility to his claim. So at the moment, I'm guessing that the first brother Dave is real and the second brother Dave is Larry. But from now on, I'm going to call him Slim Shady.

Update: Ah, this gets funnier and funnier. I went back and did an IP address search on the two Daves and on Larry. Will it come as a shock to anyone to find out that Dave #2 - the alleged "real Dave" - is actually Larry? Yep, same IP address - 207.200.116.13. The first Dave's IP is portable, but starts with 71.132.*. So in fact, the second Dave is really Larry pretending to be his brother. He even opened up another screen name on AOL and sent me an email that concludes:

I trust that you will promptly take appropriate action.

Indeed I will. And I believe it is appropriate for me to laugh my ass off.

Update #2: Someone is now posting comments at Larry's blog as "Shemp Fafarman". Hysterical.

More like this

Well folks, the mystery has been solved once and for all. And - surprise, surprise - Larry is lying through his teeth. Here's what he had to say on his blog when someone told him that I had traced the IP addresses and found that the 2nd Dave came from his IP address: I don't know if Ed Brayton said…
DaveScot and Larry Fafarman really should take their act on the road, I think. I'd pay money to see these keystone cops try and explain legal concepts to each other and argue about it, wouldn't you? Dave's post on jury nullification continues to provide much amusement. As Dan said in a comment,…
Attention conservation notice: A couple thousand words of reply to questions about why I think NCSE does what it does, delivered in my capacity as a random blogger not as an NCSE staffer. People who don't care about accommodationism or about how I read the NCSE website should probably just go…
You've gotta hand it to DaveScot - when he goes down, he does so while ducking directly into the punch. Here's his absolutely perfect reply to everyone who pointed out that he fell for a scam. I could not have written it to make him look more ridiculous if I'd done so myself. You could not have…

Be honest Ed. You made all three dullards up to entertain us. The odds of the genepool creating not three but one numpty like that are [does some spurious / bogus math] beyond the UPB, ergo ED DID IT.

Rich: you can't make such an assertion unless you can do some more spurious/bogus math to prove that there's a greater probability that "EDDIDIT."

On a more serious note, I'm really glad that family has no connection to mine...

"Hi. My name is Larry. This is my brother Dave, and this is my other brother Dave."

ROTFL.

By Tracy P. Hamilton (not verified) on 25 May 2006 #permalink

And this, folks, is the fake Dave (the real Dave uses the typekey username Davefxx; the fake one (Larry) uses the typekey username DavidFafarman. The IP address on this one, once again, is 207.200.116.13 - Larry's IP address. The IP on the real one a few minutes ago is 71.132.192.64. I'll post the proof up top momentarily.

Why Shemp? Did Curly and Moe get banned already?

Oh, come on, we all know Shemp was the coolest Stooge...

By George Cauldron (not verified) on 25 May 2006 #permalink