Judge Jones' Reward

I mentioned the other day that I thought Judge Jones was being particularly courageous to issue this ruling because it essentially means the end of any hope for an appeals court nomination. A close White House ally has now confirmed that:

"This decision is a poster child for a half-century secularist reign of terror that's coming to a rapid end with Justice Roberts and soon-to-be Justice Alito," said Richard Land, who is president of the Southern Baptist
Convention's Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission and is a political ally of White House adviser Karl Rove. "This was an extremely injudicious judge who went way, way beyond his boundaries -- if he had any eyes on advancing up the judicial ladder, he just sawed off the bottom rung."

Land was on Hannity and Colmes last night making absurd arguments about the ruling. He actually said that since one side argued that ID was science and the other side argued that it wasn't, the judge had no right to decide which one was right. Huh? That's what judges do, evaluate arguments and decide who's right.

Update: Sandefur has a much more thorough takedown of Land's statement over at PT.

More like this

I thought I'd post what some legal scholars are saying about yesterday's ruling, since a good many of them have blogs and have responded. First, Timothy Sandefur writes at the Panda's Thumb: Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District is a major victory for science and a major blow to those who have…
In all the brouhaha over James Dobson being given secret information, I have maintained all along that James Dobson is lying. He first claimed to be given information by the White House that was "confidential" and that he "probably shouldn't have" that made him endorse the Miers nomination, but he…
Numerous websites are reporting that Chief Justice Rehnquist has informed the White House of his intent to retire at the end of this term. The Chicago Tribune is reporting that the White House has been busy interviewing potential nominees and quotes anonymous White House sources on the short list…
As I mentioned, I did get to hear a few minutes of Sen. John Cornyn's (R-Texas) opening remarks in this morning's Alito confirmation hearing and got a good chuckle out of it. As is common among partisans of both parties, he portrayed he and his party as motivated solely by a concern for truth and…

Thank god for lifetime appointments.

"Thank god for lifetime appointments."

Not necessarily all of them.

We could work hard to conceive of a convoluted future that has the Dems taking over all of Congress, impeaching Bush/Cheney, leading to the new Dem Speaker of the House becoming President and appointing Jones to the SCOTUS.