do they know what they like?

'cause it is not art?

The WaPo did something interesting:

they convinced a top violinist to take his strad to the DC metro and busk at rush hour

seven people stopped to listen, twenty seven gave money total of $32.17 - $20 of that came from the one person out of 1000 who recognized the musician.

the good thing - every single child passing through turned to listen and tried to stop
the bad thing - every one of their parents dragged them away without stopping

- there are pubs in England where big time rock stars sometimes come and play unplugged and unannounced. I think Elvis Costello also did some guerilla busking, but was usually recognised, he probably couldn't do it now because of cell phone flash crowds.

I am astonished no one recognised the play early and phoned it in to gather a crowd.

I am sure I would not have recognised the player had I been there, I like to think I would have stopped.
Unless I was late for a panel, of course...

(h/t tpm

Tags

More like this

I just finished reading an interesting piece from the Washington Post (thanks Steve), which basically asked whether "objective" beauty and talent from one of the world's finest musicians, playing one of the world's most expensive instruments, can be demonstrated when seen out of context. More…
Hey, maybe this fits into the framing debate. The famous violinist Joshua Bell stood in a Washington DC subway station, playing Bach on his Stradivarius, in a test to see how many commuters would stop and appreciate the magnificent music. A few people stopped, but no crowd formed, and he got a…
This story in the Washington Post has been getting a lot of attention. The reporter convinced world-famous violin virtuoso Joshua Bell to play for 45 minutes in a busy Washington subway station, as an experiment to see if passersby would recognize his amazing talents and reward him appropriately.…
Let me be the millionth person to link to the Washington Post article about the busking virtuoso. Let me also agree with Kevin Drum about the reasons nobody listened: Plus, of course, IT WAS A METRO STATION. People needed to get to work on time so their bosses wouldn't yell at them. Weingarten…

Not many people on the planet can play Bach's Chaconne, so I would have known something unusual was going on if I heard a busker playing it. I wouldn't have recognised Joshua Bell, but I am certain that I would have stayed to listen; the Chaconne has that effect on me.

Well, I'll never know if I would have stopped.
But, a few years ago I was at Covent Garden with the munchkin (1 yrs old then) and a very good string quartet was playing in the market.
It not only kept me listening, but kept the newly toddling munchkin entertained for quite a while, while we waited for the rest of our party. In fact we listened till they stopped playing (and yes, I did give a couple of quid when they passed the hat round).
They had a decent crowd, but I got the sense that it was not unusual for good performers to be there, some good music schools very nearby and it is a friendly area.