The "Two Cultures" discussion at the Intersection

C.P. Snow fans, prepare to head over to the Intersection to partake in an upcoming online discussion of Snow's famous "Two Cultures" address. In their new article, "The Culture Crosser," Sheril and Chris portray Snow as a sort of science policy prophet:

It helps to think of Snow as an early theorist on a critical modern problem: How can we best translate highly complex information, stored in the minds of often eccentric (if well meaning) scientists, into the process of political decision making at all levels and in all aspects of government, from military to medical? At best that's a difficult quandary; there are many ways in which the translation can go wrong, and few in which it can go right. Yet World War II had demonstrated beyond question that the nations that best marshal their scientific resources have the best chance of survival and success, making sound science policy an essential component of modern, advanced democracies.

Is that what Snow had in mind when he gave his speech - the best way for a nation to leverage science to make good policy? If so, why did it provoke such a vitriolic reaction from critics like FR Leavis? Reading Snow today, do you think the cultural divisions he perceived have been ameliorated or exacerbated by the burgeoning of the sciences?

More like this

There were some great comments on our last post announcing the "Two Cultures" 50 year anniversary conference at the New York Academy of Sciences. I wanted to build on that discussion, but haven't gotten around to it until now. So let's address some of the more noteworthy points; meanwhile, I also…
Chad Orzel, of Uncertain Principles, has a nice article today in Inside Higher Ed about the value of science blogging, both in his own career and in the scientific process in general. This is a view that I of course agree with and think is important, and Chad brings a unique perspective on the…
Unscientific America: How Scientific Illiteracy Threatens Our Future is the new book by Chris and Sheril of The Intersection (formerly on ScienceBlogs, now at Discover), and they were kind enough to include me on the list of people getting review copies. It turned up on Friday (after I'd already…
There are two interdisciplinary science meetings coming up that you should consider attending, in NYC and DC. Strangely enough, the ubiquitous Chris Mooney is speaking at both of them. Hmmm. From April 30-May 1 in DC will be the AAAS Forum on Science and Technology Policy, which is a somewhat…

Hi Jessica,
Thanks for blogging our discussion, which I'm about to kick off. I think if you read the "Two Cultures" lecture next to Snow's "Science in Government" speech of just a year or so later, then our interpretation gains a lot of force--especially as Snow was himself a government science adviser. The problem is, nobody ever reads the "Science in Government" speech....