Of White Whales: or, The More Things Change

Here's a quote for you. It's one of the ones that should make you wonder whether you should laugh or cry:

And, doubtless, my going on this whaling voyage, formed part of the grand programme of Providence that was drawn up a long time ago. It came in as a sort of brief interlude and solo between more extensive performances. I take it that this part of the bill must have run something like this:

"Grand Contested Election for the Presidency of the United States.

"WHALING VOYAGE BY ONE ISHMAEL.

"
BLOODY BATTLE IN AFFGHANISTAN."

That, if you haven't guessed from the name in the middle line, comes from Herman Melville's 1851 masterpiece, Moby-Dick.

Barnes and Noble should thank Chris Dodd. His selection of Herman Melville's Moby-Dick as one of the "best books" boosted their sales by at least the $9.95 that I plunked down for a copy last week. (The State of Texas might also want drop Dodd a quick note thanking him for the extra 82 cents of tax revenue.) I had to do it. After becoming the first Democrat to show a spine this century, Dodd caught my interest. When I noticed that his take on Melville's whale of a book included the line, "Every time I read this endlessly fascinating novel," I was really taken aback. Who on earth would read Moby Dick more than once? I know I swore it off forever after reading it in ninth grade. What sort of person would voluntarily subject themselves to the book more than once?

Then I remembered - I never actually read the book. I read the first fifty or so pages, left Queequeg when he was putting his boots on under the bed, jumped to the ending, and relied on the amazing Mr. Cliff for everything else.

That's when I really started thinking. The book is legendary, and not merely for its heft. It had just been recommended by someone I wanted to learn more about. And, for reasons I might elaborate on at another time, I'd been thinking a lot about the dangers of the obsessive pursuit of perceived wrong-thinking, regardless of the cost or consequences. Taking some time and reading the book seemed like a really good idea. I picked it up on Thursday, and started reading it this morning.

I'm not done yet - or, for that matter, very far into it (although I have passed my previous high-water mark). I've mentioned all of this merely by way of explaining why I made a couple of the neighbors look up at my balcony this morning, and wonder why I was laughing so hard.

More like this

This was asked on a listserv I'm on, and I decided that the question is interesting enough to share here -- largely because I'm interested in how you would answer. In an article titled "What is a Generally Educated Person?" in the Fall 2004 issue of AAC&U's Peer Review, Jerry G. Gaff asks…
Move over, all you monkey trials from primordial American history (and from, like, 2005). Here comes a high stakes whale trial that has been lost to our memories, but that we really should learn about and remember. I'm talking about the 1818 court case Maurice v. Judd, chronicled in Princeton…
Euro-update 4: Sperm whale perception Tuscany is about the last place you might think to go to speculate about the visual system of a whale, but when you're spending three weeks relaxing in a secluded villa, you have a lot of reading time. I've been reading Moby-Dick. Herman Melville describes the…
In my recent WSJ article on age and creativity, I didn't have space to discuss the fascinating research of David Galenson, an economist at the University of Chicago who brings together a vast array of evidence to better understand the nature of creative production over time. Galenson divides…